An analysis of a paper on the german legal system and discusses the ramifications of the dissolution

It gives more legal certainty than decisions of the institutions described above.

court in german

Nevertheless, Lord Cooke has started the discussion about unimpeachable common law rights. The protection of rights in New Zealand by quasi-judicial agencies and by ordinary courts does not reach the same extent and quality. Only if the law can be enforced is it able to keep its supreme position.

In addition to this, there are provisions which are so fundamental that they can not be altered at all, not even by constitutional amendments.

Legal tradition in germany

Throughout, however, he remained convinced that certain legal traditions, above all French civil law, were relatively effective in promoting social ties. The supremacy of Parliament hinders any solid and explicit boundaries of parliamentary freedom to legislate. It is hard to establish the exact role and status of the new possibility for the courts to make a declaration of inconsistency. In reaction to the historical experiences, the Basic Law tries to avoid any concentration of authority. One nation can learn from the successful and unsuccessful experiments of other nations. However, the premier is not directly chosen by the electorate, but appointed from the majority or coalition group in the legislature. Second, no constitution, however well designed, can protect a a political system against effective usurpation. Their task is to resolve conflicts between businesses and their customers. The criticism of New Zealand's constitutional conventions does not mean that conventions should not be a source of law at all.

What are the main domestic sources of law? Do courts now have to allow argument to the effect that an Act of Parliament should not be recognised because it infringes fundamental common law rights?

The Constitution Act brings together the most important aspects of the constitution. This order describes the hierarchy of these sources from a practical point of view, although the theory of the interaction between European law and, in particular, constitutional law is highly complex.

German legal history

However, there is an exception for general rules of international customary law, which are an integral part of federal law Article 25, Basic Law. Although there is a Bill of Rights in New Zealand, its consistency and its enforceability are less than its German counterpart. Whilst it could be argued that social capital encompasses numerous other things as well, such as cultural, economic and human capital Carpiano and Kelly, , overall we follow the tenor of the debate and suggest that, as an expression of social solidarity, social capital will be higher in civil law states, hence: H1: Civil law countries have higher levels of social capital than common law ones. Basis for limitations In Germany, the supremacy of law requires that only law itself can justify a restriction of rights. By what means can the constitution be amended? If asked, most New Zealanders would reply they have never heard of the Acts above. The principle of official investigation applies in criminal and administrative proceedings. The concept of rigidity At the beginning of the comparison between Germany and New Zealand one parameter was set to determine which country offers the better constitutional solution. Consequently, without a statutory authority they cannot limit rights. Greenhouse, ; he was a profoundly political thinker, with a deep interest in the role of the power and the state within this nexus, and alert to the dangers of economic liberalism in the absence of societal mediation Fournier, : 48; Joas, Constitutional principles reflect the fundamental understanding of the legal system. No constitutional Act has the character of superior law or is entrenched against amendments. Although having different historical roots, the German and the New Zealand systems can be described as democratic and parliamentary. There is also the important concept of 'legal reservation'.

It is the framework within which the law is created, serviced and administered. Property All these persons may own property and hold it for its own sake house, clothes etc or as a business or investment office blocks, factories, shares, savings accounts. Moreover, it seems likely that countries with common law traditions would be more receptive to neoliberal governance, given that judge-made law appears to be more responsive to the needs of property owners than civil law legislation La Porta et al.

This means that not only citizens are subject to its declarations, but also the state.

Rated 8/10 based on 25 review
Legal systems in Germany: overview